Adding a Second Pet to Your Insurance

Adding a Second Pet to Your Insurance

When we got our second dog, I assumed I'd just add her to our existing policy like adding a driver to car insurance. It doesn't quite work that way. Each pet needs their own coverage, though most insurers offer discounts when you have multiple pets with them.

Here's what I learned about adding a second pet to your insurance setup.

What You'll Need

  • Your new pet's basic information (breed, age, weight)
  • Veterinary records if they have any health history
  • Your existing policy details
  • Time to compare whether staying with your current insurer makes sense

Step 1: Understand How Multi-Pet Works

Unlike adding a family member to health insurance, pet insurance policies are individual. Your second pet gets their own policy with:

  • Their own premium based on their species, breed, age, and location
  • Their own deductible (annual or per-incident)
  • Their own waiting periods starting from enrollment
  • Their own coverage limits

The "multi-pet discount" reduces the premium for each pet, but you're still paying for and managing separate policies.

Step 2: Check Multi-Pet Discounts

Most insurers offer 5-10% off each pet when you insure multiple pets together. The discount typically applies to all pets on your account, not just the additional ones.

Contact your current insurer to confirm:

  • What discount they offer for multiple pets
  • Whether the discount applies automatically or needs to be requested
  • If there's a maximum number of pets eligible

The discount alone shouldn't drive your decision. A 10% discount on an expensive policy might still cost more than a competitively priced alternative.

Step 3: Decide: Same Insurer or Different?

Using the same insurer is simpler. One login, one billing relationship, one company to deal with for claims. But it's not always the best financial choice.

Consider different insurers if:

  • Your pets have different health profiles (breed-specific coverage matters)
  • Your current insurer doesn't cover your new pet's species well (exotic pets, birds)
  • Another company offers significantly better rates for the new pet
  • You're unhappy with your current insurer's claims experience

The administrative inconvenience of multiple insurers is minor compared to having appropriate coverage for each pet.

Example Scenario

We have a Lab (prone to hip dysplasia) and a French Bulldog (respiratory issues, allergies). The Lab is with an insurer known for good orthopedic coverage. The Frenchie is with a different company that specifically covers brachycephalic breeds' common issues without excessive exclusions. Each pet has coverage suited to their risks.

Step 4: Time the Enrollment Strategically

Your new pet starts waiting periods fresh, regardless of how long you've had coverage for your first pet. Plan accordingly:

  • Enroll before any health issues develop
  • For puppies/kittens, enroll at 8 weeks if allowed
  • If adopting an adult pet, enroll immediately even before the first vet visit

Waiting periods typically run 14 days for accidents and 14-30 days for illnesses. Some conditions (hip dysplasia, cruciate issues) may have 6-12 month waiting periods. Check the specific terms for your new pet's likely health risks.

Step 5: Set Up the Policy

If staying with your current insurer, log into your account and look for "Add Pet" or contact customer service. You'll provide:

  • Pet's name, species, breed
  • Date of birth (or estimate)
  • Spayed/neutered status
  • Any known health conditions

Choose coverage levels. You can match your first pet's coverage or customize based on the new pet's needs. A young, healthy mixed breed might need less coverage than a purebred with known genetic risks.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

  • Assuming the discount makes same-insurer automatic: Always compare total costs
  • Waiting too long to enroll: Any condition that develops becomes pre-existing
  • Copying coverage exactly: Each pet's risks differ
  • Forgetting to update payment methods: Second pet means second monthly charge
  • Assuming combined deductibles: Each pet's deductible is separate

What to Expect

Adding a second pet typically takes 15-20 minutes if staying with your current insurer. New quotes from other companies might take longer.

Your monthly insurance cost will roughly double minus any multi-pet discount. For most households, expect $60-150/month for two dogs or $40-80/month for two cats, depending on coverage levels and pet demographics.

Managing two policies is straightforward once set up. Most insurers let you switch between pets within the same account portal. Claims are filed separately for each pet.

More on Dogs